Addison Reyes
15 min readMay 11, 2024

Looking for the perfect roasting pan to bring your culinary creations to life? Look no further! In this article, we’ll be highlighting the top enamel roasting pans on the market, designed to deliver a deliciously crisp exterior and tender, juicy interior. From top brands to affordable options, we’ve got you covered. Get ready to elevate your cooking game with our carefully curated selection of enamel roasting pans.

The Top 10 Best enamel roasting pans

  1. Enamel Roasting Pan: Large Capacity, Versatile, and Easy to Clean — Experience the ultimate cooking versatility with our Enamelware Large Roasting Pan in Red Marble — lightweight, shatterproof, and perfect for baking, grilling, and more!
  2. Pioneer Woman Sweet Rose Enamel Roaster with Rack — The Pioneer Woman Sweet Rose 16-inch Enamel on Steel Roaster with Rack offers a large capacity, easy-to-clean design, and sturdy durability for perfect, even cooking of family-sized meals.
  3. KitchenAid 11" Enameled Cast Iron Square Grill & Roasting Pan — Blue Velvet — Craft mouth-watering dishes effortlessly with the KitchenAid 11" Enameled Cast Iron Grill Pan, boasting superior durability, easy cleaning, and exceptional heat retention for perfect searing.
  4. Grey Marble Enamel Roasting Pan for Large Cooking — The Enamelware Large Open Roasting Pan Grey Marble provides a versatile, lightweight, shatterproof, and easy-to-clean experience that excels in baking, grilling, and more in your kitchen or barbecue set-up!
  5. Martha Stewart Thayer Martha Blue Enamel Roaster Pan — Celebrate effortless cooking with Martha Stewart’s Thayer 16" Enamel on Steel Roaster Pan, boasting durability, stain-resistance, and a Martha Blue finish for versatile, scratch-resistant, and stylish culinary experiences.
  6. Golden Rabbit Enamel Roasting Pan: Superior Cooking Experience — The Golden Rabbit Solid Enamel Roasting Pan from Pottery Barn is not only attractive and easy to clean, but also boasts excellent craftsmanship and stain resistance, all while being BPA, lead, latex, and phthalate-free.
  7. Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel Roasting Pan Cookware in Mint Green — Martha Stewart’s 16-inch enamel on steel roasting pan with a mint-green finish is a culinary delight, offering even heat distribution and easy clean-up, making it the perfect addition to your kitchen.
  8. Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel On Steel Multi-Purpose Roasting Pan for Large Meals — Transform your culinary experience with the Martha Stewart 16 inch enamel-on-steel roasting pan, promising perfect roasts and easy clean-up for ultimate kitchen inspiration.
  9. Enamel Cast Iron Baker Dish for Casseroles and Roasting (14.8" x 8") — Red — Experience exceptional cooking and versatile storage with the HAWOK Enameled Cast Iron Baker Dish Rectangle Roaster Pan, designed for even heat distribution and compatibility with multiple cooktops.
  10. Martha Stewart Mint Roasting Pan with Rack for Casseroles — Experience Martha Stewart’s exceptional 18" Enamel on Steel Roasting Pan, featuring an enameled finish for even heating, wide handles for easy transport, and a durable steel construction for hassle-free cookware.

As an Amazon Affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you

Reviews

Enamel Roasting Pan: Large Capacity, Versatile, and Easy to Clean

enamelware-large-roasting-pan-red-marble-1

This red marble enamel roasting pan packs a punch with a generous 3-quart capacity, ready to tackle your culinary masterpieces with ease. The versatile design doesn’t just stand out in the kitchen, but also on the grill, oven, stovetop, and campfire.

Its lightweight nature and shatterproof construction make it a cinch to handle, while its easy-to-clean surface simplifies post-cooking chores. Dishwasher safe for added convenience, just ensure it’s not used in the microwave. Say goodbye to tiring cleanup routines and hello to a cook’s delight with this enamel roasting pan.

Pioneer Woman Sweet Rose Enamel Roaster with Rack

the-pioneer-woman-sweet-rose-16-inch-enamel-on-steel-roaster-with-rack-size-20-inch-1

The Pioneer Woman Sweet Rose enamel roaster and rack set is truly a kitchen’s best friend. With its beautiful floral design and sturdy build, it effortlessly captures attention and is an ideal choice for preparing family-sized meals. The deeply enameled roaster can hold not just meat, but also a variety of vegetables, ensuring that everything cooks evenly.

The nesting rack keeps the food elevated, collecting any drippings at the bottom, allowing for full heating. Moving the roaster or rack from oven to table is simple, thanks to their convenient handles, and cleaning up afterwards is a breeze. If you’re looking to elevate your cooking skills, this enamel on steel roaster with rack will make a fantastic addition to your kitchen.

KitchenAid 11" Enameled Cast Iron Square Grill & Roasting Pan — Blue Velvet

kitchenaid-11-enameled-cast-iron-square-grill-and-roasting-pan-blue-velvet-1

I recently tried out the KitchenAid 11-inch Enameled Cast Iron Grill Pan in Blue Velvet, and it has quickly become one of my favorite kitchen tools. The enameled finish makes for easy cleaning and keeps the cast iron from rusting or chipping.

The raised ridges on the pan provide excellent airflow, resulting in deep, even browning and perfect sear marks. The thick cast iron body ensures even heat distribution, making it ideal for searing on the stovetop or roasting in the oven.

This cast iron grill pan is oven-safe up to 500°F and induction-suitable, making it versatile for various cooking methods. Although it is heavy, it has built-in handles that make it easy to handle and transport.

The only downside I experienced was the need to wash the pan thoroughly after each use, as food tends to get stuck in the grooves. Nevertheless, the quality and performance of the KitchenAid 11-inch Enameled Cast Iron Grill Pan far outweigh the minor inconvenience of occasional cleaning.

Grey Marble Enamel Roasting Pan for Large Cooking

enamelware-large-open-roasting-pan-grey-marble-1

I recently decided to try out this Enamelware Large Open Roasting Pan in my daily life. The first thing that caught my attention was its versatile design. It was perfect for baking, grilling, and even roasting, making it a go-to kitchen essential. The lightweight and shatterproof nature of the pan made it easy to handle and clean (thanks to the baked-on porcelain finish).

However, I also noticed that it was not intended for microwave use. This became an issue when I tried to heat up leftovers for dinner, as I had to resort to using another dish. On the positive side, it was dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze.

Overall, this Enamelware Large Open Roasting Pan lived up to its reputation of being durable and versatile. While there were a few minor drawbacks, it was still a great addition to my kitchen collection.

Martha Stewart Thayer Martha Blue Enamel Roaster Pan

martha-stewart-thayer-16-enamel-on-steel-roaster-pan-w-stainless-steel-rack-martha-blue-1

The Martha Stewart Home cooks will appreciate the versatile Thayer 16-inch Enamel on Steel Roaster Pan as their trustworthy sidekick in any kitchen. With its beautiful blue enameled exterior, it’s not just sturdy and durable, but also visually appealing. Elevate food by baking with the removable stainless steel rack, and say goodbye to the challenge of uneven cooking. Perfectly designed for lasagna, casseroles, and roasted vegetables, this steel pan offers ease and convenience.

The enamel interior is not just aesthetically pleasing but also highly efficient at cleaning up after meals. The easy-to-clean surface ensures quick food preparation and minimal mess. The cast handles provide a safe and secure grip when moving the pan, making serving and cleaning a breeze.

While some customers may have faced issues with manufacturing defects or shabby packaging, these instances have been few and far between, and a large group still stands by this pan’s high-quality craftsmanship and functionality. Invest in this exceptional piece of bakeware and elevate your cooking experience.

Golden Rabbit Enamel Roasting Pan: Superior Cooking Experience

golden-rabbit-solid-enamel-roasting-pan-white-pottery-barn-1

I’ve been cooking with the Golden Rabbit Solid Enamel Roasting Pan lately, and it’s a delight. The enamelware might sound like old, outdated kitchen utensils, but this roasting pan has proven me wrong. Its unique construction, made of carbon steel coated with porcelain enamel and a stainless-steel trim, has made my cooking experience a breeze. It’s a versatile piece, equally perfect for soups and sauces, and it’s a breeze to clean after every use, thanks to its dishwasher-safe feature.

The stain-resistant ability of this pan is fantastic. I used to worry about scorching the bottom, which often led to spending more time scrubbing away the stains. But this pan, with its high-quality craftsmanship, proved that it’s indeed durable and efficient.

One of my favorite aspects is its lightweight nature. Sometimes, we crave the benefits of Dutch ovens, but their heavy construction often puts us off. This Golden Rabbit pan is a great substitute, satisfying my cravings while being much easier to handle.

Sure, there are a few downsides, like the slightly fragile lid that might not always fit correctly. But overall, I’ve been extremely satisfied with my experience using this roasting pan. Its attractiveness is undeniable, coupled with the ease of cleaning and the outstanding craftsmanship — it’s truly a kitchen workhorse. I highly recommend investing in one.

Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel Roasting Pan Cookware in Mint Green

martha-stewart-16-inch-enamel-on-steel-roasting-pan-cookware-in-mint-green-1

Introducing the Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel on Steel Roasting Pan Cookware in a vibrant Mint — Green color. With this versatile pan, you can effortlessly roast a succulent chicken and later remove the rack to bake your favorite lasagna. The enamel on steel construction not only makes your food cook evenly, but it also simplifies the cleaning process. The wide handles ensure a sturdy grip for easy maneuvering. However, be sure to hand wash this pan to maintain the enamel coating for a perfect finish.

This 2-piece cookware set includes a 16-inch pan with 2-inch handles and a 14.25-inch rack. The pan measures 20 inches in length, 12.25 inches in width, and weighs 3.9 pounds. The rack measures 14.25 inches in length, 9 inches in width, and weighs 0.80 pounds. With its visual appeal and excellent craftsmanship, this pan will surely become your go-to for all your cooking needs.

Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel On Steel Multi-Purpose Roasting Pan for Large Meals

martha-stewart-16-inch-enamel-on-steel-roasting-pan-cookware-mint-1

Imagine waking up on a chilly morning, the aroma of a perfectly roasted chicken filling your home. That’s the magic of the Martha Stewart 16-inch Enamel on Steel Roasting Pan Cookware. The mint-colored enamel adds a pop of freshness to your kitchen, while the steel construction ensures even heating and easy clean-up.

From roasting a succulent chicken to baking your favorite lasagna, this pan’s removable rack makes it versatile and convenient. The wide handles provide a sturdy grip, making it easy to move around the kitchen. Just make sure to hand wash this pan to keep the enamel on steel coating looking pristine for years to come.

With its beautiful design and high-quality craftsmanship, this pan will inspire you to spend more time in the kitchen.

Enamel Cast Iron Baker Dish for Casseroles and Roasting (14.8" x 8") — Red

hawok-enameled-cast-iron-baker-dish-rectangle-roaster-pan-red-color-1

The HAWOK Enameled Cast Iron Baker Dish is a versatile rectangular roaster pan that’s perfect for preparing casseroles and baked goods. Its robust construction ensures even heat distribution, allowing you to cook and serve with ease. This pan is compatible with gas, electric, ceramic, and induction cooktops and is oven safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

The vibrant red color adds a touch of style to any kitchen, while its compact design makes it perfect for storing when not in use. Although it’s not dishwasher safe, its durable finish makes cleaning a breeze. Overall, this enameled roasting pan is a great investment for anyone looking to elevate their cooking game.

Martha Stewart Mint Roasting Pan with Rack for Casseroles

martha-stewart-18-enamel-on-steel-roasting-pan-in-mint-with-rack-1

The Martha Stewart Steel Roasting Pan effortlessly cooks up casseroles and more with its enamel finish, ensuring even heating. Steel construction guarantees durability, while wide handles provide a firm grip for swift movements. The enamel finish not only makes cleaning effortless but also includes 1 roasting pan and 1 roasting rack for added functionality.

Hand wash only. Make your baking and roasting adventures more enjoyable with this versatile and easy-to-use pan.

Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to roasting your favorite dishes, an enamel roasting pan is a must-have kitchen essential. This versatile pan not only helps in evenly cooking your food but also adds a touch of elegance to any meal. But with so many options available in the market, choosing the right enamel roasting pan can be overwhelming. To help you make an informed decision, we have put together this comprehensive buyer’s guide.

Important Features to Consider

Before you start shopping for an enamel roasting pan, there are a few important features to consider that will help you make the right choice. These features include the pan’s material, size, shape, and cooking surface. Here’s a closer look at each of these features and why they matter:

  1. Material: Enamel roasting pans are typically made from cast iron or aluminum, with enamel coating. Cast iron pans are durable, heavy, and provide even heat distribution. Aluminum pans, on the other hand, are lightweight and heat up more quickly, but they may not retain heat as well. Regardless of the material, ensure that the pan has a strong enamel coating to prevent rust and ensure non-stick surface. 2. Size: The size of the pan will depend on the size of the meals you typically prepare. Consider the maximum number of servings you need to cook at once and choose a pan that can accommodate that number. 3. Shape: There are various shapes of enamel roasting pans, such as rectangular or round. Rectangular pans are more versatile and can be used for different types of dishes, while round pans offer better heat distribution and are ideal for roasting larger cuts of meat. 4. Cooking Surface: The cooking surface of the pan plays a crucial role in even heat distribution and food quality. Look for a pan with a smooth, non-stick surface that is easy to clean and prevents food from sticking. Additionally, consider the color of the enamel coating. Dark-colored pans retain more heat and are ideal for roasting, while light-colored pans reflect heat and are better suited for baking. 5. Handles: Enamel roasting pans should have two handles to ensure a comfortable grip when handling the pan, especially when it’s hot. Look for pans with metal or heat-resistant plastic handles that are designed to withstand high temperatures.

Buying Tips

Now that you have an idea of the important features to consider when shopping for an enamel roasting pan, here are some general tips to keep in mind. 1. Brand reputation: Choose a brand with a good reputation for manufacturing high-quality enamel roasting pans. Brands with long-lasting warranty periods and positive customer reviews are a good place to start. 2. Budget: Enamel roasting pans can vary greatly in price. Set a budget and look for pans within that range. However, don’t compromise quality for the sake of saving a few dollars. 3. Reviews: Read customer reviews before making a purchase. Reviews provide valuable insight into the pros and cons of a particular product and can help you make an informed decision. 4. Testimonials: Look for testimonials from professional chefs or food bloggers who have used the pan. Their experience can provide valuable feedback and help you make an informed decision.

Additional Considerations

Here are a few additional considerations to keep in mind when shopping for an enamel roasting pan. 1. Maintenance: Enamel roasting pans require minimal maintenance. However, it’s essential to clean them properly to prevent rust and extend their lifespan. Avoid using abrasive cleaners and steep the pan in soapy water for a few minutes before scrubbing it clean with a soft sponge. 2. Storage: Consider the storage space available in your kitchen when choosing an enamel roasting pan. Look for pans that are easy to store and stack, especially if you don’t have much space. 3. Versatility: Choose a pan that can be used for various cooking methods, such as roasting, baking, and broiling. A versatile pan will save you money in the long run and reduce the need for additional kitchenware.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right enamel roasting pan can be a daunting task, but by considering the important features, buying tips, and additional considerations outlined above, you can make an informed decision. Remember to choose a pan that fits your budget, needs, and lifestyle, and with proper care, your enamel roasting pan will serve you well for years to come.

FAQ

What advantages does an enamel roasting pan offer?

Adorned with enamel, a roasting pan boasts a variety of benefits over other materials. It’s a non-stick pan, making cooking and cleaning efforts a breeze. Moreover, it evenly distributes heat, ensuring your dish is cooked through entirely. And, as an additional bonus, it’s resistant to high temperatures. This means it can withstand oven conditions without fear of warping.

Furthermore, enamel pans’ surfaces never react with acidic foods, a feature that prevents discoloration and allows a wide array of dishes to be cooked without the dreaded chemical reactions. Regular maintenance of the pan is a cinch, as it can be wiped clean with soapy water post-usage. In conclusion, an enamel roasting pan is a versatile and practical culinary tool, ideal for both amateur cooks and seasoned professionals.

What sets an enamel roasting pan apart from a stainless steel one?

The distinguishing features between an enamel and stainless steel roasting pan lie in the materials and their cooking properties. Enamel pans possess a non-stick surface, which facilitates even cooking and quick cleanup. Stainless steel pans, however, are resistant to sticking, but not non-stick. Stainless steel pans also heat more evenly than enamel, due to better heat distribution.

Additionally, enamel pans can withstand high temperatures and can be oven-friendly without the risk of warping. Stainless steel pans, although durable, may warp if exposed to extreme heat. Aesthetically, enamel pans have a polished appearance, while stainless steel pans sport a more industrial look. Ultimately, the choice between an enamel and stainless steel roasting pan is a matter of personal preference and cooking needs.

How do I clean an enamel roasting pan?

Cleaning an enamel roasting pan is a hassle-free task. Allow the pan to cool down before washing it, then use warm water and a mild soap to clean the pan. Focus on removing food residue. Abstain from using abrasive cleaners or steel wool, as they can harm the enamel surface. Rather, employ a soft sponge or nylon brush to clean the pan thoroughly.

For stubborn burnt food residue, concoct a paste using water and baking soda, apply it to the affected area, let it sit for a few minutes, and then gently scrub with a soft sponge or nylon brush. Before washing, ensure you rinse the pan thoroughly and dry it with a soft cloth to prevent damage. With proper care, an enamel roasting pan can serve you for years, providing effective and durable cooking.

What tips do I need to know for cooking with an enamel roasting pan?

When choosing the pan size, ensure it’s compatible with your oven. Before cooking, preheat the oven to the desired temperature, as it aids in even cooking. When roasting meats, use a rack beneath the pan for better air circulation and crispier skin. For vegetables, line the pan with foil or parchment paper to prevent sticking.

When seasoning food, refrain from using metal utensils, as they can scratch the enamel surface. Instead, opt for silicone or wooden utensils. Allow the pan to cool before handling to prevent burns. Lastly, handle hot pans cautiously using oven mitts or gloves to safeguard your hands. Adhering to these tips will enable you to get the most out of your enamel roasting pan and relish delicious, evenly cooked meals every time.

What safety precautions must I observe while using an enamel roasting pan?

As with any kitchen appliance, safety is paramount when employing an enamel roasting pan. Before usage, check the pan for any cracks or damages. Abstain from placing frozen food directly onto the pan, as it may cause thermal shock and lead to cracking. When handling the pan, use oven mitts or gloves, as the heat can be intense.

In case you accidentally drop something onto the pan, be wary of any sharp edges or pieces that might cause harm. When removing the pan from the oven, exercise caution due to its weight and heat. Lastly, let the pan cool before cleaning it to prevent accidents. By adhering to these simple precautions, you can ensure a safe and enjoyable culinary experience with your enamel roasting pan.

Can an enamel roasting pan be used on an induction cooktop?

Yes, an enamel roasting pan is suitable for induction cooktops. Enamel construction consists of magnetic material, making it compatible with induction cooktops. However, ensure the enamel roasting pan is compatible with your specific induction cooktop, as different cooktops may have varying requirements.

Moreover, it’s advisable to use compatible induction cookware alongside your enamel roasting pan for optimal performance. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines or the induction cooktop’s instructions for safe and efficient cooking. With careful consideration and correct practices, an enamel roasting pan can prove an excellent option for preparing meals on an induction cooktop.

As an Amazon Affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you